The Roll the Dai Quite Belated 2021 Definitive Games of the Year List

At the end of last year’s post about the games that I enjoyed in 2020, I glibly announced that I’d see you at the start of 2022 “if I get my act together.” Well, check your calendars, y’all, because my act is like the Chinese diaspora – disparate, searching for an identity, not even sure if “together” is worth it. Then again, what better time is there than the end of 2022 to read about my favorite games of 2021?

I did scribble down a quick list of 2021 games at the start of this year and multiple times have thought about starting this post, but it somehow never was the top priority. I’ve been well, but tired. Our family has been healthy and for that, I’m grateful. Through it all, I’ve continued to turn to video games to help me feel inspired or relaxed or rejuvenated. Let’s take a quick trip down the 2021 memory lane of games that stuck with me.

10 (tie). Lemnis Gate / SuchArt: Genius Artist Simulator

I played Lemnis Gate on Xbox Game Pass (though it has since left) and I played SuchArt on Steam. Both can be purchased on Steam for $19.99 and $24.99 respectively.

I’ve put two games in this tenth spot that I wanted to highlight because they are both games that I admire, despite the fact that I don’t find myself compelled to play either of them much.

I usually will sidestep games like this for my annual list – after all, this is my definitive list! Why put games on here that didn’t even keep me playing? Because both of these games have the spark of brilliance in them and I think they just caught me in the wrong mood. I want others to play them and tell me what I missed. I want them on this list above other games that I did play and enjoy, but were perhaps a bit more conventional.

Lemnis Gate is an action-tactics game where over the course of 25 seconds, you play a 1v1 shooter game using characters with a few different abilities. Then, you do it again with a different character. You and your opponent do this a total of 5 times, all within the same time loop, layering your actions atop each other like some sort of bloody Overwatch palimpsest until the final loop plays and one of you is the victor.

It sounds like a premise that works on paper but falls apart when played, but by-and-large, it works and when it shines, it feels like you’re playing some sort of video game version of Tenet. Shoot into empty space hoping that a future enemy will walk through there? Solid strategy! Did your first agent get taken out by their second agent? Use your fifth agent to get to them first and your first agent is alive again!

It’s a bit too much for me. It makes my head spin and I can’t make snap decisions in the moment, but it’s still exhilarating and I’m so very glad that something as wild as this can exist in the shooter space.

SuchArt is almost the exact opposite vibe – a game where there’s some narrative and some mechanics to motivate you to make art, but the core game is literally just making artwork.

This is a game where you have all the time in the world to use the tools that the game gives you (and there are plenty) to just…create. The controls are a bit fiddly and I played it in Early Access when the tuning may have been a bit off, so that may have been why I didn’t indulge it for a long time, but it is rare to see a game that trusts that the creation tools it is giving the player are enough to keep someone playing.

Having watched my children, whose minds are not yet poisoned by years of game development and obsessively thinking about player motivation, spend hours in the Sims or Minecraft (or even just walking around in A Short Hike or LEGO games with no real aim) use games as a world where creation can be the entire goal makes me happy when games emerge that understand that primal need we have to create.

SuchArt lets you make art in a game, a playful space that doesn’t have the commercial or pragmatic connotations that you may get when opening “real” digital art software, but the creations that come from it are no less artistic, no less rewarding.

9. New Pokemon Snap

I played New Pokemon Snap on the Nintendo Switch. It can be purchased for $59.99

I’ve always liked so much of Pokemon – the character design, the world, the drive to catch ’em all – but somehow could never keep myself interested in the actual gameplay. There was too much to decipher about how the different elements interact and the random, endless battles eventually felt tedious.

The answer all along, of course, is a game like New Pokemon Snap. First things first, let’s try to ignore how silly it is to include the word “New” in any game that exists in a universe where time progresses, shall we?

The game hits all of the things that I want out of a Pokemon game – cute Pokemon, multiple pretty environments to look at, a core collection mechanic – and wraps it all in a theme that’s charming and more cheerful than the battling and fainting of most Pokemon games. I’m a wildlife photographer helping build out a research lab by photographing Pokemon? I’m completely on board.

It’s all a bit simple, of course – each level is on rails and there are only a handful of ways I can interact with the Pokemon I’m photographing, but there’s enough there to keep me looking for new Pokemon to snap. The online photo-sharing and friend leaderboard are also a nice touch in our modern age.

8. The Legend of Tianding

I played The Legend of Tianding on Steam, where is can be purchased for $19.99. It also is currently on Xbox Game Pass as of when this post went live.

Games, though they build worlds and systems and characters of their own, exist in our real world. I think we often forget that, especially when we play something with the goal of escaping or transcending our real-life environments.

And while there is obviously a power fantasy at the core of The Legend of Tianding – a larger-than-life side-scrolling beat-em-up that reminds me of the combo-landing excitement of something like Guacamelee – the narrative is grounded in a real folk tale of a Taiwanese hero fighting against Japanese oppressors. This tie to the history of Taiwan, an oft-overlooked Asian country that continues to fight for its own identity (primarily with China!) makes this game hit a bit closer for me.

I’m always on the lookout for more Asian representation in games (or more localized games coming out of Asian countries), and to get a game that doesn’t simply provide a character that looks like me but an entire world and story steeped in Asian history is a treat.

The game is also fun to boot, a really polished and satisfying action sidescroller.

7. ChefSquad

I played ChefSquad on Steam and Twitch. It is free to download but requires you to be streaming on Twitch to play.

From the team that created the frenetic Cook, Serve, Delicious! series comes the best sort of internal game jam experiment – a free game built for Twitch streams with the same chaotic energy as their single-player offerings but one that relies on a real sense of teamwork and collaboration.

There is a naturally smaller audience for this game – it requires the head chef to be streaming on Twitch and to have viewers willing to play by entering a bunch of commands in the chat. At the start of the pandemic, I had spent over a year doing daily Twitch streams doing the Times crossword. With the small audience and community built from that, I had the opportunity to play ChefSquad several times.

It’s not often that a game feels genuinely different, but this is the closest I’ll ever get to feeling like Gordon Ramsay. There’s something really lovely about the fact that all my sous chefs are real people, even if we are only connected via the magic of these little pixel avatars. It turns a group from a game-watching audience to a game-playing community, which is no small feat.

6. NUTS

I played NUTS on Steam, where it can be purchased for $19.99.

There’s a lot of different elements in NUTS that just make me smile.

The art is stylistic and fun and there’s a cozy Firewatch vibe. The main gameplay loop is fairly simple: go into the forest, set up some cameras, surveil some squirrels, and find out what squirrely things they’ve been up to!

It’s cute, it’s full of squirrels, and there’s a slow-burn coziness to it. At its core, the game is also a puzzle/detective game, which boosts it up a few notches for me.

Thinking back on NUTS, I think there’s also a mood it sets that was something I was looking to really dwell in last year. It was a year of transition, as our lives that had been upended from COVID were starting to settle into a routine that felt both familiar and startlingly lonely in a unique way. I think there was a need for games that felt like they gave comfort in that lonely environment, even if the comfort for that loneliness was setting up cameras to spy on some virtual squirrels.

5. Overboard!

I played Overboard! on Steam, where it can be purchased for $14.99.

With every new Inkle game that emerges, I think I’m always chasing the high of playing 80 Days – that perfect blend of modular storytelling, clever writing, mechanical progression, and exciting replayability. I don’t know that Overboard! quite hits every target, but it certainly makes a valiant effort and is a lot of fun.

The premise is one that is an instant hook – it’s a murder mystery…where you’re the murderer! For any aspiring storyteller, anyone who’s thought about planning the perfect murder, or just someone who enjoys playing a narrative time-loop game, there’s lots to play with here (at times, it feels like a quicker, slicker version of something like Elsinore).

There are a few weaknesses that eventually expose themselves with repeated play: the natural sense of chasing the “perfect” solution that’s been authored and a limit to the overall amount of content when compared to something with as much depth as 80 Days.

But I don’t think Overboard! is advertising itself as something more than it is and as a clever take on the murder mystery game, it is a fun, compelling little package.

4. Wildermyth

I played Wildermyth on Steam, where is can be purchased for $24.99.

Since I brought up modular storytelling, why don’t we talk about Wildermyth? There’s a kind of interactive narrative dream where a marriage of bespoke authored content meets smart procedural generation. The prize? A game that feels like each session has been written especially for you with brand new content!

Wildermyth answers this challenge with aplomb by using what amounts to short stories sprinkled with tactics battles, strung together with just enough logic and an overall narrative skeleton that makes the whole thing feels coherent.

When the planets align, it can feel magical, as if the game engine is a smart and responsive dungeon master. The character customization is varied and wacky and the stories available that aren’t on the main story path are memorable and have lasting effects. At worst, the chapters of the story can feel disjointed and a bit random, but I suppose that’s the price we pay for shooting for the stars.

There’s enough interesting stuff going on with the actual tactics and strategy to keep me on my toes, and though I find the time-management on the overworld map a bit fiddly, the ambition of the narrative system more than makes up for it.

3. TOEM

I played TOEM on Steam, where it can be purchased for $19.99.

There’s a fun little sub-genre of games that has, as a key mechanic, the taking of photos – see Pokemon Snap above, Umurangi Generation, or INFRA. Regardless of the art direction or narrative, put a camera in my virtual hands and I get a bit giddy.

TOEM has a fairly simple photography system – point and zoom and shoot – but wraps it in a cozy, adorable package full of charm and collection and exploration. The characters you meet all have their own little quirks but it’s a nice world to play around in and there’s a real comfort to the optimistic idea that helping the community and being a good person comes down to getting the right pictures.

Progression in TOEM is straightforward but satisfying. The art is nice to look at. The writing is funny without being cloying. It’s a really sweet little package. And in 2021, a time when comfort felt like it was sometimes in short supply, sweet little packages of games could feel like more than just entertainment.

2. Inscryption

I played Inscryption on Steam, where it can be purchased for $19.99.

An absolutely thrilling experience, Inscryption does something that very few video games can do: genuinely surprises me over and over again. It impresses me as a developer potentially more than as a player – I want to talk about all the ways this game subverts expectations and plays with what a video game can even be – but I’ll also admit that the main gameplay is a well-polished deck-builder.

There’s this somewhat inane conversation that erupts every once in a while in the discourse about whether video games can be art (the answer is, of course, yes), but I do think there’s something interesting to be said about the intent of the art of each video game. Like the differences between a Marvel movie, a Spielberg classic, and an experimental arthouse indie, games also go to different amounts of effort to be intentionally artistic. The effort that went into Inscryption is clear and the artistry shines through.

Daniel Mullins also made Pony Island (which I enjoyed quite a bit) and The Hex (which I have yet to play) before Inscyption, and there is a clear thematic throughline in all these works in exploring what video games are, what they can be, and what it means to play one. Inscryption is not only a work where the effort and love of the developer shows, but also one where the end result is just a powerhouse of a game to play.

1. Unpacking

I played Unpacking on Steam, where it can be purchased for $19.99. It also is currently on Xbox Game Pass as of when this post went live.

Are you tired of me talking about the cozy vibe I was looking for back in 2021? Are you rolling your eyes when I compare a game to a warm blanket? Are you looking for sharp corners in your UI and vaporwave color schemes?? Well, too bad, because Unpacking is my tip top game of 2021.

Unpacking does pretty much everything right. The pixel art is spot-on and inviting, the premise is easy-to-grasp, the controls are intuitive, and perhaps most importantly, unpacking objects and exploring where to put them is just fun.

There is a story that unfolds across the various levels that, while reminiscent of many other coming-of-age stories, is touching and – in the end – hopeful and optimistic. What’s more impressive is that this whole narrative unspools entirely through environmental and object-based storytelling, as a prime example of how to show something instead of telling about it.

Another aspect of Unpacking that felt especially timely was the relationship that we have with the objects we are surrounded by. In a year when our homes felt like both sanctuary and prison, there were more times than one when I looked at the objects around me and thought about what they meant. For better or worse, we imbue our possessions with emotions and memories and meaning. Unpacking reminds us of how much humanity is contained within our stuffed animals that we’ve had since childhood and the hobbies we pick up along the way.

It really is everything: a warm blanket, an introspective look at how commercialism turns into nostalgia and sentimentality, a really fun way to spend a few hours doing something that usually takes way longer in real life. It’s a great little experience and one I’d heartily recommend to everyone.

New Game Plus

Let’s be honest – writing this look back on my favorite games of 2021 in December of 2022 is already stretching the limits of my memory, so I don’t have much bonus content for you in this post.

As games also release in multiple stages (Early Access, 1.0, Live Service), it’s sometimes hard to know when a game is considered released anymore.

Here are a few errant thoughts I had when trying to finish writing this post:

  • A cozy game that just missed the list: Dorfromantik
  • A lonely game about identity and community that couldn’t quite stick the landing for me but was a good attempt nonetheless in my eyes: Sable
  • If you’re looking for that sort of thing, there is a real mindless satisfaction to PowerWash Simulator
  • Xbox Game Pass continues to be an incredible value in terms of discovering and playing a wide variety of exciting indie games

Welp.

We did it. I posted my best of 2021 list before 2022 ended. Please clap. What does this bode for my best of 2022 list? Only time will tell.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *